Lang Lang with SF Symphony Musicians December 9, 2008
Riding high on a wave of international acclaim after the Beijing Olympics Opening Ceremony and being chosen as one of People Magazine’s 2008 Sexiest Men Alive, pianist Lang Lang breezed into San Francisco last week in a versatile series of performances. Ranging from a solo piano recital, to Chopin’s Piano Concerto No. 1, Lang Lang ended the week with a chamber music concert with violinist Nadya Tichman and cellist Peter Wyrick. I caught his chamber music concert with San Francisco Symphony musicians on Sunday night at the Davies Symphony Hall.
Anyone who is even a little familiar with the classical music world knows fair well that despite sold out houses and household name status, Lang Lang is an easy target ridiculed by both the press and the public. With an over-the-top animated style where his hands fly a good two feet off of the piano and flourishes are common, he is admittedly really fun to watch but can catch the audience off guard as familiar piano pieces can sound unrecognizable peppered with aggressive personal stylings. A critic from London’s Telegraph declares, “he needs a mentor to tell him to grow up and not be so silly” in an article titled, “Lang Lang: A bravura display of preening”. In a NY Times article, he is the poster child for an article titled, “When Histrionics Undermine the Music and the Pianist”. Out of the three concerts he put on (solo piano recital, concerto, or chamber music), the concerto is best suited to showcase Lang Lang’s brazen showmanship; the recital and chamber music require subtle transparency that Lang Lang isn’t well known for. But because I could only make the Sunday night concert, I was unexpectedly but pleasantly surprised when I found the chamber music setting to offset Lang Lang’s melodramatic style in an advantageous way.
Granted, Lang Lang is still most comfortable when left to his own devices and free will, but if forced to be a team player, Lang Lang can do it to an admirable degree. Tempo and volume were more controlled as he had to match the two other players, and his virtuosic technical abilities were able to shine through. Despite muddy pedaling at the beginning of the concert, at times Lang Lang seemed to fly when playing a shower of notes with clarity and lightness. As a group, Tichman, Wyrick, and Lang Lang made a unified trio because stylistically, all three are musicians that perform with stirring lyricism rather than being exact technicians. As a result, moments of true poetry emerged. However, I couldn’t shake the feeling that this concert was a tad under rehearsed with one too many technical fumbles and pitchy moments. Things never strayed into the precarious however and stayed solid all the way through. The concert opened with the sunny Schubert Trio No. 1 in B flat major, a world in which the music evolved seamlessly over time. The third movement Scherzo flit in and out of major and minor keys. The smokier Tchaikovsky Trio in A minor fit the character of this trio better as the players were able to let go a little and dig deeper into the drama and suspense of the music. But this freedom made Lang Lang sound like a different musician from the Schubert trio - more confident, more soloistic, and less careful. This confidence also affected the tempo of the piece, as moments in the first movement got faster and faster with the strings trying to keep up. The second movement was a theme and variations, a smorgasbord of segments strung together with breaks that gave it a disjointed yet monotonously repetitive feel without enough logic to fully engage. It still possessed the melodies that Tchaikovsky is famous for, including a moment where the piano sets the tempo with a funeral march-like strictness with the strings pulling the melody forward with heartrending emotion. The third movement ended on a typical Lang Lang way on a self indulgent note, where he drew out the quiet ending to an extreme to the point where the audience didn’t quite know when the piece was over as he dramatically held his hands over the piano for what seemed like minutes. Sounds of eyerolls echoed around the symphony hall - or maybe it was just in my own head.
The audience went crazy the entire concert, applauding after every single movement and even in between variations in the second movement of the Tchaikovsky trio. Whatever reservations I had seemed to be completely lost on the almost completely sold out house. Overall, the concert on Sunday night demonstrated the quality of professionalism of all three musicians, in spite of sufficient rehearsal time or not at the end of a busy week for Lang Lang in which he presented three different concerts in a very short period of time. Anyone who’s played in a chamber music group knows how difficult it is to be in such a transparent and collaborative environment. I still can’t help but to wonder if playing with Lang Lang is like playing with a bomb that might unpredictably go off at any minute, but the musicians kept it together and even managed to squeeze in moments of really great music. Violinist Nadya Tichman played with a lovely quiet solidarity and sensitivity. Cellist Peter Wyrick is a gem, performing with genuine heart and musicality pouring from every pore, showcasing the rich sounds of the cello to the highest degree. It was a unique setting that showcased individual talents more than I would ever see in a San Francisco Symphony concert and a great opportunity to see Lang Lang in a more collaborative and unique chamber music setting.
Other links:
- Kosman’s reviews in the SF Chronicle, of LL’s solo recital (”Lang Lang batters the piano“) and his concert with the SF Symphony (”Wigglesworth, Lang Lang a Hit at Symphony“). You can sense the polarizing effect LL has by reading the comments.
- You can pedal like Lang Lang with Lang Lang Adidas sneakers for a mere $125! He really is a marketing machine.
- Lang Lang: His Life So Far - NY Times by Tommasini





















